Case law for experts

The judgments every medico-legal expert should know: the duty to the court, independence, previous criticism and liability, credibility in personal injury claims, and artificial intelligence.

Courts rely on expert evidence, and they judge it by the standards these cases set. Each entry gives the citation, what the court decided and what it means for an expert’s report or oral evidence. Links go to the free full text on the National Archives and BAILII.

Section 1 of 5

The expert’s duty to the court

An expert’s overriding duty is to help the court on matters within their expertise. That duty overrides any obligation to whoever instructs or pays them (CPR 35.3; in criminal cases, Part 19 of the Criminal Procedure Rules).

The Ikarian Reefer

National Justice Compania Naviera SA v Prudential Assurance Co Ltd [1993] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 68

The classic statement of an expert’s duties. Expert evidence should be, and be seen to be, the independent product of the expert. The expert should state the facts and assumptions the opinion rests on, say when a question falls outside their expertise, and say when an opinion is provisional because the information is incomplete.

Vernon v Bosley (No 1)

[1997] 1 All ER 577 · BAILII: [1996] EWCA Civ 1217

Thorpe LJ’s image of the expert walking straight down the middle of the road. The expert belongs on neither the claimant’s side nor the defendant’s.

Kennedy v Cordia (Services) LLP

[2016] UKSC 6 · BAILII

The Supreme Court set out four questions for admissible expert evidence (at [44]). Will it assist the court? Does the witness have the necessary knowledge and experience? Is the witness impartial? Is there a reliable body of knowledge behind it? An opinion without stated reasoning is of no value (at [48]). What carries weight is the reasoning, not the conclusion.

TUI UK Ltd v Griffiths

[2023] UKSC 48 · BAILII

An expert report that is not challenged in cross-examination will generally not be rejected on the strength of criticisms made only in closing submissions. The Supreme Court distinguished a bare assertion, with no reasoning, from reasoning that is merely open to criticism. Setting out the reasoning in full is what protects an opinion.

Edwards-Tubb v JD Wetherspoon plc

[2011] EWCA Civ 136 · BAILII

A party that wants to change expert will normally have to disclose the first expert’s report as the price of permission. This deters “expert shopping”. As Hughes LJ put it, the report should say exactly the same whoever instructed the expert.

O’Connell v Ministry of Defence

[2025] EWHC 2301 (KB) · BAILII

After surveillance evidence, the claimant’s pain expert concluded that she no longer met the diagnostic criteria for complex regional pain syndrome. The court emphasised that an expert whose opinion changes must say so clearly and explain why. The claim was dismissed and the claimant was found fundamentally dishonest.

Back to contents

Section 2 of 5

Independence and conflicts of interest

Any connection that could affect, or appear to affect, an expert’s independence must be disclosed at the outset. Late discovery can cut the weight of the evidence or make it inadmissible. Where our practice provides a second report in the same case, it comes from a separate expert who reaches their own independent opinion.

EXP v Barker

[2017] EWCA Civ 63 · BAILII

A defendant doctor’s expert had a long professional relationship with him, including training and co-authoring papers, and did not disclose it. It emerged in cross-examination. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge’s decision to give the evidence greatly reduced weight, and said admitting it at all was finely balanced.

Pinkus v Direct Line Group Ltd

[2018] EWHC 1671 (QB) · BAILII

The court considered the evidence of two neuropsychologists where a mentoring relationship relevant to the evidence had not been disclosed. Mentoring, supervisory and other professional relationships that could bear on an opinion must be disclosed.

Muyepa v Ministry of Defence

[2022] EWHC 2648 (KB) · BAILII

Cotter J reminded experts that they are not part of anybody’s team (at [284]). An expert who writes as an advocate for the instructing party loses the court’s trust.

Back to contents

Section 3 of 5

Previous criticism, liability and contempt

Experts can be sued, held in contempt and required to disclose past judicial criticism. Each of these follows from the court’s reliance on expert evidence.

JSC Commercial Bank PrivatBank v Kolomoisky

[2025] EWHC 1987 (Ch) · BAILII

Trower J held that parties must tell the court about previous adverse judicial comments on their expert, even from unrelated proceedings. The criticism of the expert in that case had not been disclosed. Experts should keep a record of judgments that comment on their evidence, and tell instructing parties about them.

Jones v Kaney

[2011] UKSC 13 · BAILII

The Supreme Court abolished expert witnesses’ immunity from claims in negligence. A psychologist had signed a joint statement, drafted by the opposing expert, that did not reflect her views. Never sign a joint statement without checking it against your own opinion.

Liverpool Victoria Insurance Co Ltd v Zafar

[2019] EWCA Civ 392 · BAILII

A GP who made false statements in a medico-legal report was found in contempt of court. The Court of Appeal treated false statements by experts as especially serious, because courts rely on them, and indicated that immediate custody will usually follow.

Back to contents

Section 4 of 5

Credibility, fundamental dishonesty and surveillance

In personal injury claims, expert evidence often decides whether a claimant is believed. Experts should state the facts their opinion depends on, and say how it would change if those facts proved wrong.

Section 57, Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015

Statute

If a claimant has been fundamentally dishonest, the court must dismiss the whole claim, including the honest parts, unless that would cause substantial injustice. Dishonesty is judged by Ivey v Genting Casinos [2017] UKSC 67 (BAILII) (at [74]). Whether it is fundamental follows LOCOG v Sinfield [2018] EWHC 51 (QB) (BAILII) (at [61]). Cotter J’s structured questions are in Muyepa (above, at [388]).

Williams-Henry v Associated British Ports Holdings Ltd

[2024] EWHC 806 (KB) · BAILII

The claimant had a genuine, moderately severe brain injury. She gave experts accounts of her disability that her social media and surveillance contradicted. The whole claim was dismissed for fundamental dishonesty, and experts who relied uncritically on her self-report were criticised.

Palmer v Mantas

[2022] EWHC 90 (QB) · BAILII

The counterpoint. A fundamental dishonesty allegation failed, the claimant was found honest and she recovered about £1.68 million. The defendant’s expert was criticised for overreaching: partisanship damages credibility on either side.

Hayden v Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust

[2016] EWHC 1121 (QB) and [2016] EWHC 1962 (QB) · BAILII: 1121 and 1962

Late surveillance footage was shown to one side’s experts before the court had given permission to rely on it. The court expected experts to put excluded material out of mind. It also treated asking an expert to comment on footage without the claimant’s response to it as a breach of best practice.

O’Leary v Tunnelcraft Ltd

[2009] EWHC 3438 (QB) · BAILII

Surveillance disclosed shortly before trial was refused as an ambush. Experts should ask whether permission has been given before commenting on surveillance.

Taylor v Forth Valley Health Board

[2025] CSOH 103 · BAILII

A man had a kidney removed after inadequate consent and went on to develop severe somatic symptom disorder. The Court of Session found that the admitted negligence materially contributed to the disorder and awarded £904,000. Pain that is genuinely experienced but psychologically driven can found a substantial award.

Back to contents

Section 5 of 5

Use and misuse of artificial intelligence

Courts expect anyone who puts material before them to check it personally. Using AI does not shift that responsibility.

R (Ayinde) v London Borough of Haringey; Al-Haroun v Qatar National Bank

[2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin) · BAILII

In two unrelated cases, submissions cited authorities that did not exist or did not say what was claimed. In one, 18 of 45 citations were fictitious. The Divisional Court, led by Dame Victoria Sharp P, referred the lawyers to their regulators. It warned that generative AI tools are not reliable for legal research and that professionals remain personally responsible for what they put before the court.

Abbott v Ministry of Defence

[2026] EWHC 941 (KB) · BAILII

In the military hearing loss group litigation, Garnham J rejected a machine-learning diagnostic method relied on by the claimants. Nobody could explain how it reached an individual result (at [353]-[356]), and its training data assumed the diagnosis it was meant to test (at [357]). A court must be able to understand how a method produces its result where the outcome is disputed.

Civil Justice Council, Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report

29 October 2026

The CJC recommends amending the Civil Procedure Rules so that experts must declare AI use where it generates or influences the substantive content of a report. This is a recommendation, not yet a rule. A fuller explanation is in our note on what the CJC has recommended.

Back to contents

To instruct one of our experts, see Contact us. This page describes the law in general terms and is not legal advice. Case law checked to November 2026.