Home

Can a defendant deny involvement and still raise diminished responsibility?

A defendant does not have to admit a role in a killing to advance diminished responsibility. What the Court of Appeal decided in Richardson v R [2026] EWCA Crim 1131, and what a psychiatric report needs to address.

FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY EXPERTSDenial of involvementand diminishedresponsibilityRichardson v R [2026] EWCA Crim 1131 andwhat a psychiatric report needs to addressforensicpsychiatryexperts.co.uk

In Richardson v R [2026] EWCA Crim 1131, the Court of Appeal confirmed that a defendant need not admit a role in a killing before advancing diminished responsibility. The practical difficulty is establishing what the defendant’s mental condition meant for their ability to understand, judge or control their own conduct at the time.

What the Court of Appeal decided

Richardson was convicted of murder in 2020. He maintained that he did not take part in the attack, and diminished responsibility was not advanced at trial. In its judgment of 28 August 2026, the Court of Appeal considered an application to introduce fresh psychiatric and psychological evidence in support of a proposed appeal.

The court accepted that Richardson had ADHD at the time of the killing and was not taking medication for it. There was also a history of depression and anxiety, but the evidence did not establish whether either was present at the relevant time or what effect it had. Two psychiatrists gave evidence. The court rejected the first psychiatrist’s opinion as internally inconsistent, noting that he had assumed Richardson was the person who did the stabbing. It accepted the evidence of the second, who could not conclude, given the passage of time and the lack of evidence about Richardson’s thought processes leading up to the killing, that his responsibility was substantially impaired.

The court stressed that a denial of involvement does not bar the partial defence. It also explained why, outside rare cases, it will be very difficult to assess substantial impairment without evidence about the defendant’s role and mental processes at the time. The court found the fresh evidence capable of belief, but held that it afforded no ground for allowing the appeal. It also found no reasonable explanation for the failure to advance the defence at trial, observing that a defence not run at trial may be raised on appeal only in exceptional cases and with a persuasive explanation for the omission. It refused all the applications, including leave to appeal against conviction and sentence. Read paragraphs 69–71 and 82–89 of the judgment.

What a psychiatric report needs to address

Under section 2 of the Homicide Act 1957, the defence must establish that an abnormality of mental functioning arose from a recognised medical condition, substantially impaired at least one of the specified abilities, and caused or significantly contributed to the defendant’s conduct in the killing. The abilities are understanding the nature of their conduct, forming a rational judgement and exercising self-control.

For instructing solicitors, a useful starting point is to give the psychiatrist the prosecution’s account of the alleged conduct, the defendant’s account, and any contemporaneous material that may help reconstruct their mental state. Where the accounts differ, identify the factual assumptions on which an opinion is sought. The report should explain whether the opinion changes under a different account and say plainly when the available evidence cannot support a reliable conclusion. In Richardson, one psychiatric opinion failed partly because it rested on an account of the killing that the defendant did not accept.

The value of Richardson is that it shows where an instruction can fall short. Asking whether the defendant has ADHD may answer a diagnostic question. Asking what the condition did to a particular ability, at the time of the alleged conduct, is the question the report needs to answer. The case is also a reminder to consider the question before trial: raising diminished responsibility for the first time on appeal requires a persuasive explanation for not running it earlier.

Read more about diminished responsibility assessments at Forensic Psychiatry Experts.

Published 21 November 2026. This article describes the law in general terms and is not legal advice.

Instructing an expert

Send a short outline of the case and the questions for the expert. We reply with a quote within one working day.

contact@forensicpsychiatryexperts.co.uk

0116 380 5641