Home

Fitness to plead in the magistrates’ court

There is no formal fitness to plead procedure in the magistrates' court. How the court deals instead with a defendant who cannot take part in their trial, the cases that set out the steps, and what a psychiatric report needs to cover.

FORENSIC PSYCHIATRY EXPERTSFitness to plead inthe magistrates’ courtSection 37(3), the leading cases, and whata psychiatric report needs to coverforensicpsychiatryexperts.co.uk

Most criminal cases start and finish in the magistrates’ court, and many of the most vulnerable defendants are found there. Yet the formal fitness to plead procedure in the Criminal Procedure (Insanity) Act 1964 applies only in the Crown Court. In the magistrates’ and youth courts the problem is handled through the Mental Health Act 1983 and a short line of High Court decisions.

Is there a fitness to plead procedure in the magistrates’ court?

No. In R (Singh) v Stratford Magistrates’ Court [2007] EWHC 1582 (Admin) the Divisional Court confirmed that there is no statutory procedure for trying the issue of fitness to plead in the magistrates’ court (para 25). Magistrates should not hold a Crown Court-style hearing on fitness. Instead, where a defendant’s mental condition may prevent a fair trial, the court looks to two provisions that work together.

Which provisions does the court use instead?

Section 37(3) of the Mental Health Act 1983 allows the magistrates’ court, if it is satisfied that the defendant did the act or made the omission charged, to make a hospital order or guardianship order without convicting them. It is available only for imprisonable offences, and only where the medical criteria for the order are met. That requires evidence from two registered medical practitioners, at least one approved under section 12, and for a hospital order, evidence that a bed will be available within 28 days.

Section 11(1) of the Powers of Criminal Courts (Sentencing) Act 2000, which remains in force, requires the court to adjourn for a medical examination and report where it is satisfied the defendant did the act but considers that an inquiry into their mental or physical condition ought to be made. Each adjournment is limited to three weeks if the defendant is remanded in custody, or four weeks on bail.

What steps should the court follow?

Singh and Blouet v Bath and Wansdyke Magistrates’ Court [2009] EWHC 759 (Admin) set out a straightforward sequence:

  1. The court tells the parties that a section 37(3) order is a possibility and invites submissions.
  2. It makes sure it has up-to-date medical evidence before any fact-finding or trial begins. In Blouet the court stressed this point (paras 9 and 15).
  3. Where a section 37(3) order is possible, the court first decides whether the defendant did the act or made the omission. If that is not proved, the defendant must be acquitted outright.
  4. If it is proved, the court considers whether to make a hospital or guardianship order, adjourning under section 11 for further reports where needed.
  5. If the medical evidence shows that no section 37(3) order is possible whatever happens, the case proceeds to an ordinary trial, unless there is some other compelling reason not to.

In Blouet the District Judge had treated “trial” and “finding that the defendant did the act” as the same thing. The Divisional Court said the statutory procedure was perfectly simple and set out the order above.

Can the defence of insanity be run in the magistrates’ court?

Yes. Singh confirmed that insanity is a common law defence available in the magistrates’ court, and that section 37(3) cannot take it away. Unlike in the Crown Court, where the special verdict leads to a range of disposals, a successful insanity defence in the magistrates’ court results in an acquittal. The defendant has no absolute right to a trial of insanity where section 37(3) is in play: the court decides whether trying that issue is in the interests of justice. The court in Singh also suggested that these cases are well suited to a District Judge.

What happens in the youth court?

The same statutory framework applies. In Crown Prosecution Service v P [2007] EWHC 946 (Admin) the Divisional Court held that a youth court can stay proceedings as an abuse of process where a child cannot participate effectively, but that this is exceptional and should rarely happen before evidence has been heard. The court has a continuing duty to keep the child’s ability to participate under review, and may switch to a fact-finding exercise if a fair trial is not possible. The court also said that medical evidence will rarely provide the whole answer: it is the court’s own view of the child’s level of understanding that decides whether the trial goes ahead.

Does it matter if the offence is triable either way?

A defendant who is too unwell to take part in the allocation decision is not thereby put beyond the reach of section 37(3). The courts have held that the magistrates’ power to make an order without conviction can be used in either-way cases even though the defendant cannot meaningfully elect Crown Court trial.

Is the law going to change?

Probably, but not yet. The Law Commission’s 2016 report, Unfitness to Plead (Law Com No 364), recommended a modern test based on capacity for effective participation and the extension of the procedure to the magistrates’ and youth courts. The government’s response of October 2023 accepted most of the recommendations, including that extension, and in October 2026 the Ministry of Justice again said in Parliament that the law needs updating. No legislation has yet been introduced.

What should a psychiatric report cover?

Because the court’s route runs through section 37(3), a useful report for the magistrates’ or youth court usually needs to address more than fitness alone:

  • Capacity to participate. Whether the defendant can understand the charge, follow the proceedings, instruct their representatives and give evidence, using the Pritchard criteria as a reference point, and what adjustments, such as an intermediary or ground rules, might make participation possible.
  • Mental disorder and the section 37 criteria. Diagnosis, whether the criteria for a hospital or guardianship order are met, and whether a bed is likely to be available. The court needs two doctors for this, at least one approved under section 12.
  • Mental state at the time of the alleged offence. Whether there is a basis for an insanity defence, or for arguing that the mental element was absent.
  • Currency. The court must have up-to-date evidence before the fact-finding stage, so a report prepared some months earlier may need an addendum.

Our psychiatrists are all consultant forensic psychiatrists approved under section 12(2). Where two medical opinions are needed, a second report can be arranged within the practice from a separate expert who assesses the defendant and reaches their own opinion independently. To discuss a case, email contact@forensicpsychiatryexperts.co.uk or call 0116 380 5641.

Related: Fitness to plead – Insanity – Case law for experts

Published 20 November 2026. This article describes the law in general terms and is not legal advice.

Instructing an expert

Send a short outline of the case and the questions for the expert. We reply with a quote within one working day.

contact@forensicpsychiatryexperts.co.uk

0116 380 5641